Some people have to learn that God never gives you more than you can handle
31 August 2004 Bob’s post a while back about the comfort that God brings when you don’t make the cheer squad reminds me of a kind of response you ofter get from theists to the problem of evil: They think of cases like this, and note how failing to make the cheer squad might actually be a good experience of growth for little Marie, and then extrapolate that the lack of hardships wouldn’t be as good a world.
And when 15-year-old Marie Massey gets her heart broken — like when she didn’t make the varsity cheerleading squad recently — she knows she’ll find comfort in church. “Right after I didn’t make (cheerleading), the sermon that week was about how everything happens for a reason and how God has a plan for you,” said Massey. “I know that if I have a problem, church can give you advice.”
So, sometimes when bad things happen — like you don’t make the cheer squad — it’s really for the best. Therefore, continues the theist’s “reasoning”, if you think bad things (like being buried alive in an earthquake, fried to death in a car sitting in the sun, or born with a fatal disorder) are really senseless — well then, you’re just not seeing the big picture. After all, look at Marie and the cheer squad!
